Question:
I'm not sure this is so much a question as it is something that I'm somewhat irked by, but I was frustrated by the over-simplifications on the role that gender plays in behavior and therefore achievement. The reading mentioned the issue with Kolberg's theory for instance, as being male-focused or male-dominant. It also talked about girls as having more care-based or altruistic social connections (Chapter 13, p. 436)-- this seems like it may occur moreso at the high school level but I think in first grade, at least over the course of the last year, I have seen males associate almost equally as much in this way. I also question the idea of masculine "helping" roles (i.e. boys will be more willing to help in situations that are actually dangerous- p. 442); I'd love to see this experiment done at the elementary level and see the results!
Comment:
It has been interesting for me to read these articles and work on this unit so far. I took a child development course back in high school, plus a few high school psych and sociology classes that talked about a lot of what I'm reading I have already read before. At the same time, it's totally different to read it now that I see it playing out every day in the classroom. On the other hand, when I was taking the child development class I also worked as an assistant teacher in a preschool-- it is so amazing to reflect on the difference that two years or even only a year and a half makes in terms of development!
I also thought the information presented about empathy was interesting (Chapter 13, p. 437)-- basically that around four years old, children begin to develop some sense of empathy and connection to others that helps develop sharing skills, etc. I have found that empathy is the most abstract of Rocketship's Core Values for the students. They struggle most with the idea that they should care about other people's feelings and make choices that demonstrate an understanding of others feelings and perspectives. I think, in retrospect, maybe the reason for this is partially developmental. It has always felt somewhat strange to me to teach empathy explicitly-- how do you teach someone to care? Some kids seem to be very genuinely empathetic naturally (I have 2 particularly empathetic students in my Thoroughbreds class that come to mind); many others are totally oblivious.
Quote:
"As children move into the middle and late childhood years, parents spend considerably less time with them. In one study, parents spent less than half the time with their children aged 5 to 12 in caregiving, instruction, reading and talking as when their children were younger." This quote really stood out with me because I think it's exactly what Rocketship as a community is trying to ward off with our homework packets and reading packets. We are ensuring that parents ARE taking that time; we can see on a daily basis that our students still need the support of people reading with them, giving them that attention, etc. It all plays into child development and I think we need to continue to work to make sure that those aspects aren't neglected.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
I too was frustrated by the section on gender roles and the way that biological truths were oversimplified into stereotypes. It's hard to know whether I am just putting my male and female students into these roles because this is what I have gotten used to for each gender or if they are truly acting these parts because of their gender.
The statement about developing empathy at such a young age surprised me, too, because I often think that we are expecting a lot in teaching our students to understand and apply empathy. I guess thinking about the needs of others at a basic level is far different from demonstrating true empathy, but I shouldn't discount my students' abilities to do so just because of their age.
Kate,
I remember reading that quote about caregiving and thinking the same thing. It is really great that parents are "supposed" to work with our students at home on homework and reading but the general feedback I get from a majority of my students is that their parents didn't look over the homework, they just signed it. It really makes a difference in the quality of student work that you get from parents that are super involved and helping their child at home and those parents that just sign the homework. I noticed that a parent signed homework today without even opening the students packet and making sure it was finished. I am really considering having another mandatory night that parents have to attend in regards to student homework. I wonder if I could deduct hours from them if they don't sign/check over the homework? hmm...
Post a Comment